What Are Beta Readers?
Beta readers read a manuscript before it is published and provide feedback on aspects like structure, readability, pacing, and overall enjoyability. They are not professional editors; instead, they represent the target audience and provide honest insights that help shape the final version of the book.
When Should You Bring in Beta Readers?
The ideal time to bring in beta readers is after finishing your manuscript but before hiring a professional editor. Beta readers aren’t meant to replace professional editing, but they can provide valuable feedback to help you improve your manuscript before investing in editing. This can potentially save you a lot of money if your book would have needed developmental editing, but after a beta read and revisions only requires copy editing—learn more about the types of editing here.
Who Should Be Your Beta Readers?
Readers
Readers from your target audience are invaluable beta readers. They provide a real-word reaction to your manuscript. They’ll let you know whether your book held their interest, made sense, and if they’d recommend it to others.
Writers
Fellow writers can offer a different perspective than readers. They’ll often comment on structure, pacing, and technical craft. They may pick up on elements that go unnoticed by casual readers.
Hiring Beta Readers
If you are unable to find free beta readers through your network and writers’ groups, you can always hire them. Freelancers on platforms like Upwork and Fiverr offer professional beta reading services for a fee, ranging anywhere from $5 to about $150. Paid beta readers are typically experienced in giving thoughtful, detailed feedback, but be sure to check out their reviews from clients to ensure you’re getting the best bang for your buck.
Tips for Using Beta Readers Effectively
Get More Than One Perspective
Ideally, you’ll want a mix of readers and writers for a more comprehensive range of feedback. Multiple beta readers allow you to spot trends and gather different perspectives.
You Can’t Incorporate Every Piece of Feedback
It’s important to remember that you don’t need to act on every single suggestion you receive. Look for commonalities in the feedback you receive, and pay close attention to any noted red flags, like a chapter feeling out of place.
Give Beta Readers Specific Things to Look For
Don’t simply ask your beta readers if they liked your book or not. Give them more targeted questions and areas of concern. For example, if you’re worried about pacing, ask them if there were any sections that felt slow. Below are some example questions you can give to beta readers for nonfiction and fiction:
Questions for Nonfiction:
- Did the book’s main argument or purpose come across clearly? What was it, in your own words?
- Did the book’s structure make sense? Were the chapters and sections arranged in a logical order?
- Did the content hold your interest? Were there any sections that felt slow, redundant, or unnecessary?
- Did the book provide enough depth on the subject? Were there areas where you felt more explanation was needed?
- Was the content relevant to the book’s goals? Were there any sections that felt off-topic?
- Was the writing clear and easy to understand? Were there any sections where the language became overly complex or difficult to follow?
- Did the examples, anecdotes, or references resonate with you? Did they feel relevant or appropriate for the target audience?
- Were the graphics and illustrations clear and helpful? Did they enhance your understanding of the material?
- Did the book have a strong conclusion? Did it leave you feeling satisfied, with a clear understanding of the key takeaways?
- What part of the book stood out the most to you? Why?
- What was the weakest part of the book, in your opinion? How could it be improved?
Questions for Fiction:
- Did the story grab your attention from the beginning? Did it hold your interest throughout? If not, where did it lose momentum?
- Was the main plot clear and easy to follow? Were there any parts that confused you or felt hard to understand?
- Did the pacing feel right? Were there sections that dragged or moved too quickly?
- Were any subplots introduced? Did they add to the story, or did they feel distracting or unnecessary?
- Did the story build enough tension or conflict to keep you engaged? Were you curious about what would happen next?
- Were the main characters fully developed and realistic? Did their actions and motivations make sense to you?
- Did the characters change or grow throughout the story? Did their arcs feel satisfying?
- Did the dialogue feel natural and true to each character? Were there any moments where it felt forced or out of place?
- Were the settings vivid and easy to imagine? Were there places where you wanted more detail?
- Did the chapter breaks feel natural and well-placed? Did they leave you wanting to read more?
- Was the point of view consistent and clear? Did the chosen narrative perspective (first, third, etc.) work well for the story?
- What was your favorite part of the book? Why did it stand out to you?
- What part of the book was the weakest for you, and how could it be improved?
- Did the characters’ fates feel appropriate and well-earned by the end of the story?
- Did the story remind you of any other books or authors? If so, who?
- In one sentence, how would you describe your overall impression of the book?
Focusing your beta readers on specific elements will help you receive more actionable feedback that can directly improve your manuscript.
Conclusion
Beta readers give you a glimpse into how your book will be received by your target audience, allowing you to make necessary adjustments before editing and publishing. This can also save you some money during the editing process, as your paid editor will likely be able to focus only on copy editing, rather than on identifying big-picture issues.
Owner of Aha! Editorial
Let’s talk about your writing project: https://calendly.com/ashlyn-ahaeditorial
